Financial Mentor

  • New Visitor? Start Here
  • Member Login
Member Login
×Close
  • Home
  • Calculators +
  • Resources +
  • Topics +
  • Products +
  • Coaching +
  • Podcast +
  • About +

Invest smart. Build wealth. Retire early. Live free.

FacebookTwitterPinterestLinkedIn

Wall Street Journal Got It Wrong

By Todd Tresidder
Advertising Disclosure
Financial Mentor has commercial relationships with certain companies we reference on this website. Opinions are ours alone, and we take a good faith approach to maintaining objectivity. If we wouldn’t use a product ourselves, we won’t recommend it. We strive to keep information accurate and up-to-date, however, all products are presented without warranty.

Financial Mentor has partnered with CardRatings for our coverage of credit card products. Financial Mentor and CardRatings may receive a commission from card issuers. Opinions, reviews, analyses & recommendations are the author’s alone, and have not been reviewed, endorsed or approved by any of these entities.

Real Estate Investment Returns Compared To Stocks… The Correct Way

Key Ideas

  1. Learn why WSJ's analysis of real estate investment returns is fatally flawed.
  2. Discover the simple equation you can use to determine if a real estate investment makes sense.
  3. Reveals all the factors you need to take into account when evaluating a real estate investment.

Brett Arends of the Wall Street Journal published an article claiming housing has been a lousy investment – all the way back to 1981.

Say what?!?

This article has been picked up by many media outlets, but unfortunately, it's completely and totally wrong.

Yes, believe it or not, even the venerable Wall Street Journal makes blatant mistakes by misusing statistics and applying false premises to data to derive completely incorrect conclusions.

The basic premise of the article is that housing has been a lousy investment since 1981 because the Case-Shiller index shows 4.1% growth in real estate prices, compared with consumer prices rising by 3%, leaving a paltry net return of 1.15%.

While Brett may have got the math right, the implied assumption behind the calculations is wrong, making the entire analysis wrong.

There are two main flaws with Brett's reasoning.

Get This Article Sent to Your Inbox as a PDF…

 

Is real estate a lousy investment? Wall Street Journal thought so, but their assumptions were based on misuse of statistics. I prove why real estate hasn't been a bad investment and set the facts straight here.

The Two Big Flaws In the Wall Street Journal's Real Estate Analysis

The first flaw is that Brett assumes investment real estate is purchased for cash and owned outright.

The truth is, investment real estate is seldom bought for cash. Instead, it's usually financed – typically with leverage ranging from 4:1 to 9:1 depending on the credit cycle and the type of property.

Using 4:1 to keep the math conservative means your investment return results from 5 portions of growth for every one portion of inflation.

Related: How to make more from your investing by risking less

Using the numbers from the article, a $100,000 house bought with a 20% down payment would grow in value $4,100 (100,000*.041), and inflation would cost you $600 in purchasing power (20,000*.03). The growth in “wealth” is effectively $3,500 on a down payment of $20,000, or roughly 17.5% return on investment – not the 1.15% that the Wall Street Journal claims.

In other words, investing in real estate is a leveraged play on inflation – it always has been, and it always will be, as long as people choose to finance their purchases.

That's why real estate investors got slaughtered in the 2008-2009 deflationary decline – because those deflationary losses were multiplied by leverage wiping out many investor's total equity.

It's also the reason why real estate prices rise most of the time and only rarely decline – because inflation is so persistent and consistent, except during rare credit collapses like in 2008-2009.

How To Calculate Real Estate Investment Returns Correctly

Stated simply, if you want to figure out the investment return on real estate, you can't simply subtract inflation from the price increase of the property as Arends attempts to do, because that ignores financing leverage. Instead, you must multiply the return by the leverage factor while only subtracting one part of inflation for the amount of down payment.

See My Related Book…

Investment Fraud - How Financial Experts Rip You Off & What to do about it
Amazon Kobo B&N iBooks

Using the above example, you multiply 4.1 times 5, equaling 20.5% return on your investment (down payment), then subtract 3% for loss of purchasing power due to inflation on your down payment. The result is 17.5% return on invested capital.

In addition, if you want to get fancy and look at the analysis from an investor standpoint, as opposed to a homeowners perspective, then you need to include multiple return streams from your real estate investment, and not just change in capital value.

That's the second flaw in his analysis.

For example, you would want to include cash flows from rents net of mortgage, taxes, insurance, maintenance and other costs.

Arends attempts to correct his mistaken analysis on the WSJ site by claiming any leverage benefits are offset by financing costs, but once again, he's incorrect.

Financing costs are typically offset by rent from the tenant (or imputed rent for the homeowner), leaving the above referenced leverage equation to stand on its own merit.

Related: Why you need a wealth plan, not an investment plan.

In addition, you must also include the tax advantages that accrue from real estate investment, equity built up from paying down the loan, and active appreciation from property improvements, to determine if real estate is a good overall investment (or a lousy investment as the Wall Street Journal incorrectly claims).

However, the Wall Street Journal article doesn't touch on these issues (which is a common mistake), and that's why I felt it was important to correct this flawed reasoning.

It's important to understand how the math works because flawed reasoning like this can cause you to make investment mistakes that can hurt your wealth growth.

Most real estate investors build their wealth using a very different set of mathematics as explained fully in this wealth planning course here.

I hope this article helps clarify how the math actually works in practice.

Invest Like Todd!

A better investment strategy than buy and hold - Makes more by risking less

Discover the scientific investment process Todd developed during his hedge fund days that he still uses to manage his own money today. It’s all simplified for you in this turn-key system that takes just 30 minutes per month.

Learn more… »

Want a PDF of this article? We'll email it to you!

+ =

Related...

12 Deadly Investment Mistakes You Must Avoid
3 Types of Investors - Which One Are You? Take This Test...
6 Disturbing Truths Your Financial Expert Won't Disclose… But Should
Are You Gambling Or Investing?
FM 001: The Truth About Retirement Income & Dave Ramsey's Shocking ROI and Safe Withdrawal Rate Assumptions with Wade Pfau
FM 009: How To Convert Your Volatile Investment Portfolio Into Automatic Income With Wade Pfau
How To Invest For Inflation & Deflation
How To Pick Dividend Growth Stocks - A Fully Revealed Model
Investing For Dummies - Profitably
Investment Fraud Protection: 15 Ways You're Vulnerable
My Worst Investment Loss Exposed! (And the Gut-Wrenching Lessons Learned)
New Rules For Real Estate Investing
Share:FacebookTwitterPinterestLinkedIn
This article’s comments are closed.

Financial Freedom For Smart People
Book Series

the leverage equation
Amazon Kobo B&N iBooks
how much money do I need to retire
Amazon Kobo B&N iBooks
4 Rule Safe Withdrawal Rates In Retirement
Amazon Kobo B&N iBooks
Variable Annuity Pros and Cons
Amazon Kobo B&N iBooks
Investment Fraud
Amazon Kobo B&N iBooks
Don’t Hire a Financial Coach!
Amazon Kobo B&N iBooks
  • How Anyone Can Retire Early In 10 Years (Or Less!)
  • How To Build Wealth (It’s Ridiculously Simple)
  • The Ten Commandments Of Wealth Building
  • The Secret To Happiness… And Why It Has Nothing To Do With Money
  • 12 Tips To Build Wealth For Early Retirement
  • How To Get Out Of Debt – The Complete Guide
  • The Great Bond Bubble Is Now! What’s Next…
  • Pay Off Mortgage Early Or Invest: The Complete Guide
  • What Endurance Athletes Can Teach Us About Building Wealth
  • The Parable Of The Mexican Fisherman And Investment Banker
  • FM 026: Understanding What Todd Means By “Epochal Change”
  • When is the Right Time to Buy Life Insurance?
  • How To Consolidate Debt, The Smart Way
  • How Much Does Life Insurance Cost?
  • How Anyone Can Retire Early In 10 Years (Or Less!)
  • How To Build Wealth (It’s Ridiculously Simple)
  • How Does Life Insurance Work?
  • Do I Need Life Insurance? Why Is Life Insurance Important?
  • How Much Life Insurance Do You Need?
  • Optimize Your 401(k) Today [Includes Free 401(k) Analysis Tools]
  • Are Safe Withdrawal Rates Really Safe?
  • 7 Key Reasons Why Financial Education Is Your Best Investment
  • 10 Commandments of Investment Strategy
  • Andrew Carnegie “The Gospel Of Wealth”
  • Multiple Streams Of Income – Truth Revealed
  • Retirement Planning Checklist
  • The Smart Alternative To Retirement Planning
  • What Is A Good Investment?
  • Pay Off Debt Or Build Wealth? What To Do First…
  • The Minimalist Guide To Financial Planning
  • Retirement Planning
  • Investment Advice
  • Financial Advice
  • Wealth Building
  • True Wealth
  • How Much Do I Need to Retire?

Testimonials

When I came to you I was close to having enough money to retire and wanted to know how to best manage my risk going forward. The skills you worked with me on have done just that.  This past year alone your investment course has saved me at least $75K and maybe over $100K.  Thanks again for all your help.
Dominick (Last Name Withheld To Respect Privacy)Rochester, New York
See All Testimonials Legal Disclaimer

More from Financial Mentor

New Visitors Start Here
Financial Freedom Course
A Smarter Way To Invest
Todd’s Books

Click Below To Learn How To...

Invest smart. Build wealth. Retire early. Live free.

Financial Mentor

Get Your FREE Wealth Building Tooklit:

  • FREE COURSE: 52 Weeks To Financial Freedom
  • FREE BOOK: 18 Essential Lessons From A Millionaire
  • Tools and Tips Not Found On This Site
Free instant access

Calculators

Retirement
Mortgage
Credit Card
Debt Payoff
Auto Loan
Savings
Investment
Loan
Personal Finance
Compound Interest Calculator
Debt Snowball Calculator

Learn More

About Financial Mentor
About Financial Coaching
Our Books
7 Steps To 7 Figures
Podcast
Todd R. Tresidder
Press Room
Contact

Resources

How To Invest Your Money
Recommended Reading
Recommended Tools
New Visitors Start Here
Ask Todd
Courses
Books
Audio

Facebook Twitter Google Plus LinkedIn YouTube RSS Pinterest iTunes

Home   Privacy Statement   Terms of Use   Contact Us

Copyright © 2000–2023• Financial Mentor • All Rights Reserved Worldwide
The information contained on this web site is the opinion of the individual authors based on their personal observation, research, and years of experience. The publisher and its authors are not registered investment advisers, attorneys, CPA’s or other financial service professionals and do not render legal, tax, accounting, investment advice or other professional services. The information offered by this web site is general education only. Because each individual’s factual situation is different the reader should seek his or her own personal adviser. Neither the author nor the publisher assumes any liability or responsibility for any errors or omissions and shall have neither liability nor responsibility to any person or entity with respect to damage caused or alleged to be caused directly or indirectly by the information contained on this site. Use at your own risk. Additionally, this website may receive financial compensation from the companies mentioned through advertising, affiliate programs or otherwise. Rates and offers from advertisers shown on this website change frequently, sometimes without notice. While we strive to maintain timely and accurate information, offer details may be out of date. Visitors should thus verify the terms of any such offers prior to participating in them. The author and its publisher disclaim responsibility for updating information and disclaim responsibility for third-party content, products, and services including when accessed through hyperlinks and/or advertisements on this site.
×

Yes, Send My FREE Wealth Building Blueprint!

  • E-Course: “52 Weeks to Financial Freedom”
  • Audio: Get my top tips
  • E-Book: "18 Essential Lessons From A Self-Made Millionaire"


×

Yes, Send My FREE Wealth Building Blueprint!

  • E-Course: “52 Weeks to Financial Freedom”
  • Audio: Get my top tips
  • E-Book: "18 Essential Lessons From A Self-Made Millionaire"


×

Yes, email me a screenshot of my calculator results!

We’ll email you a screen print of the calculator you just completed, exactly as it appears on your screen. We don’t save any of your data: it’s just an image. You can unsubscribe whenever you want.


Calculator screenshot sample
Sample Screenshot
×



Wall Street Journal Image
×

Enter Your Email And We’ll Send You A Convenient PDF Of This Article!



Wall Street Journal Image
×

Tell us where to send your 2 video guide showing UNCOMMON strategies for ACCURATELY calculating how much you need to retire…



Free video tutorial
×

Tell Me When The Course Is Ready!

You’ll learn how to make more by risking less.


×

Tell Me When The Course Is Ready!

You’ll learn how to calculate your retirement number with confidence.


×

Hey, I understand that buying this course is an important decision. That’s why I let you…

Test Drive The Course – FREE!
Get 5 Sample Lessons Immediately

  • No cost or obligation.
  • No hooks or gimmicks.
  • The goal is to let you experience the quality for yourself.
  • I just need your email address to send them to you.
  • You can unsubscribe anytime.
Yes! Send me 5 sample lessons
No cost or obligation. Quit any time.
The only way you lose is by not trying.
×

Take your financial strategy to the next level…

Get 5 FREE Video Lessons With Uncommon Insights To Accelerate Your Financial Growth

  • No cost or obligation.
  • No hooks or gimmicks.
  • The goal is to let you experience the quality for yourself.
  • I just need your email address to send them to you.
  • You can unsubscribe anytime.
Yes! Send me 5 sample lessons
No cost or obligation. Quit any time.
The only way you lose is by not trying.