Financial Mentor

  • New Visitor? Start Here
  • Member Login
Member Login
×Close
  • Home
  • Calculators +
  • Resources +
  • Topics +
  • Products +
  • Coaching +
  • Podcast +
  • About +

Invest smart. Build wealth. Retire early. Live free.

FM 001: The Truth About Retirement Income & Dave Ramsey’s Shocking ROI and Safe Withdrawal Rate Assumptions with Wade Pfau

Retirement Income, ROI, and Safe Withdrawal Rate

Click here to download the transcript of Wade’s top retirement income planning tips!


http://traffic.libsyn.com/financialmentor/EP1-Wade_Pfau.mp3

Podcast: Play in new window | Download | Embed

Subscribe: Apple Podcasts | RSS


In this first session of the Financial Mentor Podcast, Wade Pfau from RetirementResearcher.com, reveals deep knowledge based on published research about retirement income and return on investment assumptions for your portfolio.

What prompted this discussion was a disturbing publication by well-known author, speaker, and podcaster, Dave Ramsey claiming you can expect 12% long-term investment returns resulting in an 8% safe withdrawal rate.

Unfortunately, Dave's claims are NOT supportable by any of the data and run the risk of hurting listeners who follow his advice. In fact, as you will learn during the interview, Dave's claims are nearly double what the latest research would indicate is realistic to assume with important implications for financial planning. Wade and I set the record straight.

Related: 5 Financial Planning Mistakes That Cost You Big-Time (and what to do instead!) Explained in 5 Free Video Lessons

In this episode you will get access to one of the top minds in retirement planning research today. Wade's original research has been featured in academic peer review journals and his insights are guaranteed to take your understanding to a greater level.

In this episode you will discover:

  • How to forecast a realistic return for your retirement savings.
  • Why your investment return assumptions are critically important to your financial planning.
  • How safe withdrawal rates during retirement are calculated and what amount you should assume.
  • The critical difference between an average return assumption (statistical fiction) and the real-world compound return assumption that is affected by sequence of returns risk.
  • The difference between safe withdrawal rate research in the U.S. vs. safe withdrawal rates based on international data, and why you should be concerned.
  • How much should you save each month to achieve financial security?
  • How the wealth accumulation phase is completely different from the spending and distribution phase of retirement planning, and how to plan accordingly.
  • And much more…

Resources and Links Mentioned In The Show:

Financial Mentor Podcast Image

  • Click here for Wade's RetirementResearcher.com web site.
  • Dave Ramsey's 8% Safe Withdrawal Rate article on RetirementResearcher.com
  • Dave Ramsey's website
  • My retirement calculator for running the calculations.
  • My book teaching how much money you need to retire with financial security.

Help Out the Show:

I'm very excited to announce this first episode of the new Financial Mentor podcast. You can now expect 2 episodes per month designed to help you build financial wealth and live a wealthy life. Each episode will be packed with data driven insights and unconventional wisdom.

You can find all sessions of the podcast on Itunes where you can subscribe and/or leave a (hopefully 5 star) review…

Click here to subscribe to the show on Itunes and leave a review…

Again, if this podcast gave you value then a great way to give back is to subscribe and/or leave a review on Itunes. Just click on the link below and it should also launch Itunes on your computer…

Click here to subscribe and leave a review from inside your Itunes account…

Thanks for your support and I hope you enjoyed this episode. Please let me know what you think in the comments below…

Invest Like Todd!

A better investment strategy than buy and hold - Makes more by risking less

Discover the scientific investment process Todd developed during his hedge fund days that he still uses to manage his own money today. It’s all simplified for you in this turn-key system that takes just 30 minutes per month.

Learn more… »

Want a transcript of this podcast? We'll email it!

+ =

Related...

12 Tips To Build Wealth For Early Retirement
27 Retirement Savings Catch-Up Strategies For Late Starters
8 Shortcuts For A Simple Retirement Plan In Record Time
Are Safe Withdrawal Rates Really Safe?
Average Savings By Age: How Do You Rank?
FM 015: Early Financial Independence With Luke Landes
FM 014: Life Reimagined and The New Retirement with Richard Leider
Is It Safe To Withdraw 4% From Retirement Savings?
Optimize Your 401(k) Today [Includes Free 401(k) Analysis Tools]
The Essential Wealth Building Principle Revealed By Roth IRA Conversions (It's Not What You Think!)
The Smart Alternative To Retirement Planning
Ultimate Retirement Calculator
Share:FacebookTwitterPinterestLinkedIn

Comments

  1. Avatarmrsmelon

    Hello Todd,
    GREAT PODCAST! Glad to see you “back in action”. You sound like a professional radio guy! Great voice! And Mr. Pfau is an excellent resource….very credible! 
    As far as Dave Ramsey, I’ve read his books and listened to his radio program. Overall, he gives sound & reasonable advice. BUT, I have NEVER understood why he would promote such outlandish return assumptions and why no one has called him out on it. I am not a “financial expert” but I know enough NOT to expect this type of return (not to mention crazily high withdrawal rates assumptions). I worry about those people who follow him and may develop unreasonable expectations based on these assumptions. I wish that all his followers would listen to this podcast and learn!! 
    THANKS for sharing this with all of us. I hope everyone will share this with people that they know, love and care about. It really matters!!
    Aloha, ellen

    • AvatarTodd Tresidder

      mrsmelon You are too kind, Ellen. I appreciate your supportive words and hope these educational materials help many. Great to hear from you.

  2. Avatarjoeyjoejoe

    Now that’s what I call a good start, Todd! I’m not sure how the rest of the episodes are going to work, but this one was like a yo-yo: bouncing from strategic to practical all the time.
    Wade’s a smart fella, well-spoken, and I picked up a few tips from him. I like the intro and outtro bumper and perhaps most importantly, the way you facilitated the conversation and provided value beyond what Wade brought to the table. I’ll be listening to more and ready to leave you an iTunes review once the show “shows up.”

    • AvatarTodd Tresidder

      joeyjoejoe Awesome Joel! Thank you for all your support. I really appreciate your detailed feedback about what you noticed and what worked for you. I’m posting the next 3 shows to the site as I write this and feel they are all as strong as this one in very different ways. This is turning into a really fun project!

  3. Avatarapplejob

    Thanks for the quality content and discussion.  I look forward to listening to the other podcasts during my workout.
    In my opinion Ramsey claims the 12% return to give “hope” to the  common person with debt (his target audience) that they can get out of debt and that they can create significant wealth (become a millionare).  Ramsey props up the claim with weak industry research and references.  We should realizer In Ramsey’s world the ratios he claims really dont matter though because his goal is to get you to be frugal, to be accountable for your finances, to be debt free, to save for retirement, and to leave a legacy.  If he can get his listener to do that then he achieed his goal.  Hopefully in that process he has taught the listener enough about personal  finance to research, learn, and understand the details of personal finance on a deeper level (he constantly states you should find a professional financial coach that has the heart of a teacher).  In doing so hopefully they discover what real safe withdraw rates and returns look like.
    Perhaps the real question is not whether we agree with his ratios bur rather does the end justify the means in Ramsey’s work and his tactic in making such claims.

    • AvatarTodd Tresidder

      applejob I’m confident Dave is well aware that his investment statistics are grossly inaccurate given the negative press they have attracted. Yet he persists. 
      I’m not clear how promoting deception in investing is justified by the end goal as you discuss. It is an inaccurate deception that leads to inaccurate financial plans and financially dangerous conclusions. It also causes accurate financial planning to look bad in comparison. 
      Again, I respect Dave’s work on the “get out of debt” side of things. He has helped many. This is not about bashing Dave because he is doing good work.  Nobody is served by negativity.

      Instead, it is about trying to correct the deceptions he has promoted on the investment side that are not supportable by research and dangerous.

      • Avatarapplejob

        Thanks for the reply Todd. I agree with your comments and I believe that DR is not respecting the dangers of making such claims especially as a financial industry icon with such great reach. thanks for filling the education need on this topic with real industry research. i checked out Mr. Pfau’s blog today and could have spent hours on it, great info.
        on another note i was wondering if a whole life policy is a good tool to have to handle the sequencing issue as you can borrow against the cash value to fulfill your income requirement during a market downturn.
        another idea that crossed my mind would be to make sure you have a HELOC available (assuming your mortgage is paid or close to being paid in retirement). borrowing against an asset like a home at a low rate would be better than selling stocks at a 40% market drop.

        • AvatarTodd Tresidder

          applejob Very complex issues you raised. Too complex to be properly handled via blog comment. Thanks for understanding.

  4. AvatarMoneyPlanSOS

    I can’t believe I’m writing to you about this. I am not a CFP or brilliant scientist, I’m just a “get out of debt guy”. I am an avid Dave Ramsey show listener and have completed his counselor training course, so this will sound biased. However, I do believe that somebody should clarify some of the information you shared in this episode. Since you guest Wade Pfau said that he doesn’t really listen to DR, maybe I can bring the little clarification to the subject.BTW: Just as you did not want Ep1 to be a “Bash Dave Ramsey” show, I don’t want this to be taken as a hate letter either.
    Many times when DR says “12%” it is to encourage people to start saving something. For example: DR will say $100 a month in good mutual funds averaging 12% for 40 years grows to $1M.” Yes it is unrealistic in today’s world but it pushes people to get moving! He will also follow it up with “if I’m half wrong you’ll still have $500k” as a joke but it still helps get his point across.
    Correct me if I’m wrong but didn’t Mr. Pfau state that the withdrawal rate of 8% would decimate a 50% stocks/50% bond portfolio in less than 30 years? Dave Ramsey does not recommend a 50-50 portfolio split. He recommends all mutual funds with a mix of large cap small-cap come international, & mid-cap. It’s more volatile but also offers more growth.
    DR also uses the 8% withdrawal rate as an example. I have never heard them say that you “have” to take out that much every year. He uses it as an example to show a caller/listener that you can take a living wage out of assets, say for example $50k. He also explains that you eat into the principal in the bad years but get some of it back in the years that make more than 8% (after inflation).
    The “Save 15% into retirement” statement is a step DR teaches for people who are out of consumer debt and have an emergency fund. This allows them the ability to also save for kid’s college and possibly put more down on the mortgage. I think everyone can agree that saving for retirement takes priority over kids college but that some college saving can happen at the same time when you’re out of consumer debt.
    His advice also pushes people towards a 15 year mortgage allowing them to have a paid-for-house in fewer years – which in turn allows them to save even more for retirement and wealth building. All this is to say that 15% is a guideline that will give them freedom to do other things while having a good amount started in a retirement account.
    Finally (thank you for reading so much of this), DR advises that you work with a CFP or professional. I can’t recall a single time when he said to do it on your own but to instead find someone with the heart of a teacher so you know what you’re getting into.
    After all is said and done, if you follow DR’s advice you will be out of debt except for a house with under 15 years to pay, retirement savings has begun, and kids college is being taken care of through 529/ESAs or cash flow. All that is left to do is save even more for retirement, more than 15%, and give a bunch of money away.
    Is Dave Ramsey using 12% in his examples wrong? Maybe 12% is a higher rate of return then we will ever see – nobody really knows what the future holds. What I do know is that following DR’s Baby Steps for 7 years has caused my net worth to more than double. We have a plan, isn’t that all that matters?

    • AvatarTodd Tresidder

      MoneyPlanSOS Hi Steve, first off I really appreciate the respectful and constructive tone of your comment. I always welcome constructive criticism.

      The crux of the issue is you can play loose with the numbers and pursue emotional appeal on the “get out of debt” side of things, but not with investing. In fact, I would go so far as to say that Dave’s lack of focus on accurate numbers is probably helpful to getting under people’s skin emotionally and helping them get out debt. The formula works well for him and his followers.

      However, investing done right is all about numbers. The science of investing must be respected and Dave disrespects investing with his inaccurate and loose portrayal of statistics. It is a dangerous practice that can mislead people. Emotional investing is what causes bad decisions and destroys fortunes.

      I won’t repeat all the points made in the podcast, but I will add that your argument about a 50/50 portfolio vs. an all stock portfolio only magnifies the problem rather than fixes it. The reason an 8% withdrawal rate can’t work is because of volatility and the sequence of returns risk. Increasing the stock allocation obviously does not solve the problem as you implied.
      My position is that Dave is extremely high profile and that implies a certain level of responsibility. It is not appropriate for him to make investment claims that are 100% false and not supportable by research. It misleads and deceives people. That is not acceptable. It is irresponsible.

      Again, he has helped many people on the debt side and has my respect, but his investment advice is riddled with gross inaccuracies as clearly stated in the podcast and best avoided. Listen to him for help with your debt. He is brilliant. But I believe you would be better served to find other experts for your investment strategy.
      Hope that helps clarify…

      • AvatarMoneyPlanSOS

        Financialmentor Thanks Todd. I’m going to continue to do what I have been doing for the past few years: Learn all I can, measure my tolerance for risk, investigate possibilities, and put money into things I understand. 
        There is no harm in challenging the ideals and positions of many, only in taking action from the advice of only one.

  5. Avatarfrank_manzella

    Hello Todd,

    I just found your podcast via an interview you did with Jeff Rose and  I’m glad I did. This first episode was pretty enlightening. Often times we’re given such canned advice as if to say the same thing will work for everyone. It’s very easy for a 30 or 40 something year old to think their doing the right thing if they just save 10 to 15 % of their income into a retirement account. More of us, myself included need to really figure out what we want out of life and design a plan to get there. I think we need more professionals asking better questions of their clients instead of just assuming everyone wants to retire at 65. I like how your cognizant of what your clients want rather than just assuming what they want. The withdrawal rate wasn’t something I thought much about but its really an eye opener.

    Anyway…Thanks again

    • AvatarTodd Tresidder

      frank_manzella You’re welcome, Frank. Thank you for taking the time to share your thoughts. I really appreciate the support and encouragement.

      • Avatarfrank_manzella

        Financialmentor frank_manzella  You’re very welcome…looking forward to learning more from you…Take care Todd

  6. AvatarJim

    Wade said it best when he said “People want to believe” they can get 12% if a financial planner says so.

This article’s comments are closed.

Financial Freedom For Smart People
Book Series

the leverage equation
Amazon Kobo B&N iBooks
how much money do I need to retire
Amazon Kobo B&N iBooks
4 Rule Safe Withdrawal Rates In Retirement
Amazon Kobo B&N iBooks
Variable Annuity Pros and Cons
Amazon Kobo B&N iBooks
Investment Fraud
Amazon Kobo B&N iBooks
Don’t Hire a Financial Coach!
Amazon Kobo B&N iBooks
  • How Anyone Can Retire Early In 10 Years (Or Less!)
  • How To Build Wealth (It’s Ridiculously Simple)
  • The Ten Commandments Of Wealth Building
  • The Secret To Happiness… And Why It Has Nothing To Do With Money
  • 12 Tips To Build Wealth For Early Retirement
  • How To Get Out Of Debt – The Complete Guide
  • The Great Bond Bubble Is Now! What’s Next…
  • Pay Off Mortgage Early Or Invest: The Complete Guide
  • What Endurance Athletes Can Teach Us About Building Wealth
  • The Parable Of The Mexican Fisherman And Investment Banker
  • FM 026: Understanding What Todd Means By “Epochal Change”
  • When is the Right Time to Buy Life Insurance?
  • How To Consolidate Debt, The Smart Way
  • How Much Does Life Insurance Cost?
  • How Anyone Can Retire Early In 10 Years (Or Less!)
  • How To Build Wealth (It’s Ridiculously Simple)
  • How Does Life Insurance Work?
  • Do I Need Life Insurance? Why Is Life Insurance Important?
  • How Much Life Insurance Do You Need?
  • Optimize Your 401(k) Today [Includes Free 401(k) Analysis Tools]
  • Are Safe Withdrawal Rates Really Safe?
  • 7 Key Reasons Why Financial Education Is Your Best Investment
  • 10 Commandments of Investment Strategy
  • Andrew Carnegie “The Gospel Of Wealth”
  • Multiple Streams Of Income – Truth Revealed
  • Retirement Planning Checklist
  • The Smart Alternative To Retirement Planning
  • What Is A Good Investment?
  • Pay Off Debt Or Build Wealth? What To Do First…
  • The Minimalist Guide To Financial Planning
  • Retirement Planning
  • Investment Advice
  • Financial Advice
  • Wealth Building
  • True Wealth
  • How Much Do I Need to Retire?

Testimonials

I just wanted to send you a quick note and let you know how much I appreciate your work. The podcasts that your are creating are awesome. I always look forward to seeing a note from you land in my inbox. I’ve learned so much from you, and your podcasts are a fine addition to my mobile classroom. Thanks again for all your hard work.
Tim ByerlyAnonymous Subscriber and Wealth Builder
See All Testimonials Legal Disclaimer

More from Financial Mentor

New Visitors Start Here
Financial Freedom Course
A Smarter Way To Invest
Todd’s Books

Click Below To Learn How To...

Invest smart. Build wealth. Retire early. Live free.

Financial Mentor

Get Your FREE Wealth Building Tooklit:

  • FREE COURSE: 52 Weeks To Financial Freedom
  • FREE BOOK: 18 Essential Lessons From A Millionaire
  • Tools and Tips Not Found On This Site
Free instant access

Calculators

Retirement
Mortgage
Credit Card
Debt Payoff
Auto Loan
Savings
Investment
Loan
Personal Finance
Compound Interest Calculator
Debt Snowball Calculator

Learn More

About Financial Mentor
About Financial Coaching
Our Books
7 Steps To 7 Figures
Podcast
Todd R. Tresidder
Press Room
Contact

Resources

How To Invest Your Money
Recommended Reading
Recommended Tools
New Visitors Start Here
Ask Todd
Courses
Books
Audio

Facebook Twitter Google Plus LinkedIn YouTube RSS Pinterest iTunes

Home   Privacy Statement   Terms of Use   Contact Us

Copyright © 2000–2023• Financial Mentor • All Rights Reserved Worldwide
The information contained on this web site is the opinion of the individual authors based on their personal observation, research, and years of experience. The publisher and its authors are not registered investment advisers, attorneys, CPA’s or other financial service professionals and do not render legal, tax, accounting, investment advice or other professional services. The information offered by this web site is general education only. Because each individual’s factual situation is different the reader should seek his or her own personal adviser. Neither the author nor the publisher assumes any liability or responsibility for any errors or omissions and shall have neither liability nor responsibility to any person or entity with respect to damage caused or alleged to be caused directly or indirectly by the information contained on this site. Use at your own risk. Additionally, this website may receive financial compensation from the companies mentioned through advertising, affiliate programs or otherwise. Rates and offers from advertisers shown on this website change frequently, sometimes without notice. While we strive to maintain timely and accurate information, offer details may be out of date. Visitors should thus verify the terms of any such offers prior to participating in them. The author and its publisher disclaim responsibility for updating information and disclaim responsibility for third-party content, products, and services including when accessed through hyperlinks and/or advertisements on this site.
×

Yes, Send My FREE Wealth Building Blueprint!

  • E-Course: “52 Weeks to Financial Freedom”
  • Audio: Get my top tips
  • E-Book: "18 Essential Lessons From A Self-Made Millionaire"


×

Yes, Send My FREE Wealth Building Blueprint!

  • E-Course: “52 Weeks to Financial Freedom”
  • Audio: Get my top tips
  • E-Book: "18 Essential Lessons From A Self-Made Millionaire"


×

Yes, email me a screenshot of my calculator results!

We’ll email you a screen print of the calculator you just completed, exactly as it appears on your screen. We don’t save any of your data: it’s just an image. You can unsubscribe whenever you want.


Calculator screenshot sample
Sample Screenshot
×



Retirement Income, ROI, and Safe Withdrawal Rates with Wade Pfau
×

Enter Your Email And We’ll Send You A Convenient PDF Of This Article!



Retirement Income, ROI, and Safe Withdrawal Rates with Wade Pfau
×

Tell us where to send your 2 video guide showing UNCOMMON strategies for ACCURATELY calculating how much you need to retire…



Free video tutorial
×

Tell Me When The Course Is Ready!

You’ll learn how to make more by risking less.


×

Tell Me When The Course Is Ready!

You’ll learn how to calculate your retirement number with confidence.


×

Hey, I understand that buying this course is an important decision. That’s why I let you…

Test Drive The Course – FREE!
Get 5 Sample Lessons Immediately

  • No cost or obligation.
  • No hooks or gimmicks.
  • The goal is to let you experience the quality for yourself.
  • I just need your email address to send them to you.
  • You can unsubscribe anytime.
Yes! Send me 5 sample lessons
No cost or obligation. Quit any time.
The only way you lose is by not trying.
×

Take your financial strategy to the next level…

Get 5 FREE Video Lessons With Uncommon Insights To Accelerate Your Financial Growth

  • No cost or obligation.
  • No hooks or gimmicks.
  • The goal is to let you experience the quality for yourself.
  • I just need your email address to send them to you.
  • You can unsubscribe anytime.
Yes! Send me 5 sample lessons
No cost or obligation. Quit any time.
The only way you lose is by not trying.