Financial Mentor

  • New Visitor? Start Here
  • Member Login
Member Login
×Close
  • Home
  • Calculators +
  • Resources +
  • Topics +
  • Products +
  • Coaching +
  • Podcast +
  • About +

Invest smart. Build wealth. Retire early. Live free.

FacebookTwitterPinterestLinkedIn

Is It Safe To Withdraw 4% From Retirement Savings?

By Todd Tresidder
Advertising Disclosure
Financial Mentor has commercial relationships with certain companies we reference on this website. Opinions are ours alone, and we take a good faith approach to maintaining objectivity. If we wouldn’t use a product ourselves, we won’t recommend it. We strive to keep information accurate and up-to-date, however, all products are presented without warranty.

Financial Mentor has partnered with CardRatings for our coverage of credit card products. Financial Mentor and CardRatings may receive a commission from card issuers. Opinions, reviews, analyses & recommendations are the author’s alone, and have not been reviewed, endorsed or approved by any of these entities.

Instead Of Looking At The “Rules,” Look At The Investment Strategy Used

Key Ideas

  1. Learn how to factor in market valuations and conditions when saving for retirement.
  2. Why buy and hold isn't the end-all-be-all strategy it's made out to be.
  3. The three avenues you can take to safeguard your retirement income.

How much can you withdraw from retirement savings each year without jeopardizing your financial security?

Conversely, how much money do you need for retirement so you can afford your current level of spending?

These are interesting questions that Larry presented in a recent blog comment that I will address below…

Specifically, Larry asked, “I have a question regarding retirement withdrawal rates in a long term bear market. The standard thinking is that a retiree can safely withdraw 4% of their portfolio each year. However, common sense tells me that if you retired with a high allocation in stocks and the P/E ratio was over the historical mean of about 15 at the time, your chances of using a 4% withdrawal rate successfully go down substantially during a long term bear market. Do all the studies on safe withdrawal rates take into account high market valuations? Do they even look at P/E ratios? Will the 4% rule hold up in a long term bear market? Thoughts?”

All I can say, Larry, is you are a man after my own heart. You’re questioning authority and not accepting the status quo commonly passed off as investment wisdom.

I like your independent thinking and agree wholeheartedly with your concerns. Let's look at this issue more closely…

Get This Article Sent to Your Inbox as a PDF…

 

Withdrawal Rate Image

Before explaining the solution to this question, let me provide a little background information about withdrawal rates so everyone is on the same page.

The 4% withdrawal rule is mathematically the same thing as the “rule of 25.” It’s an oversimplified, but useful guideline stating you need roughly 25 times your first year's spending to have enough money to retire. That’s mathematically the same thing as spending 4% of your assets annually.

This rule has been stress-tested using a variety of assumptions and Monte Carlo theory, and it’s surprisingly robust; however, it’s not perfect.

It provides a high confidence interval under most simulations using U.S. data, but that doesn't mean it can’t fail.

Wade Pfau tested the 4% Rule using the same portfolio allocations on international data and it failed 100% of the time. Shocking, but true.

In short, it's a simple rule of thumb designed to provide a quick shortcut for people who don't want to think too deeply about the subject.

Related: Why you need a wealth plan, not an investment plan.

It’s a reasonable guideline that more experienced readers will question and choose to adjust based on market valuations and conditions during retirement.

For example, a more robust rule to be used when market valuations are higher is spending 3% of your retirement nest egg, otherwise known as the rule of 33.

It's similar to the rule of 25, but with a little higher threshold requiring 33 times your first year's spending. This is safer, but it's also more difficult to achieve.

Getting back to Larry's question, why would market valuations cause concern that you should increase your retirement savings or lower the percent you can spend annually?

Well, the way the math works is pretty straightforward.

Your expected investment return over a 15-20 year horizon (relevant for most retirees) for a diversified portfolio of stocks is inversely correlated to the market valuation at the beginning of the holding period.

That sounds like a mouthful, so let me explain.

Data provided by Ed Easterling of Crestmont Research analyzes 20 year average investment returns for the S&P 500 over the period 1919-2008, and ranks them into deciles from best to worst.

The lowest investment return decile showed an average starting P/E of 19, and an average annual investment return of 3.2% over the following 20 year period – pretty pathetic and certainly not sufficient to support a 4% withdrawal rate.

Related: How to make more from your investing by risking less

Conversely, the best performing decile showed an average starting P/E of just 10 with an average annual return of 13.4% over 20 years – clearly more than enough to support more than a 4% withdrawal rate.

In other words, the higher the market valuation at the beginning of the holding period, the lower the expected return from a diversified portfolio of stocks. The lower the market valuation, the higher the expected return.

(Readers who find this subject interesting would likely enjoy Ed Easterling's excellent and highly recommended book Unexpected Returns: Understanding Secular Stock Market Cycles.)

These statistics are extremely robust, and the research has been verified using different time periods and data sets by multiple researchers.

I cited Easterling's research just because it’s easily accessible, but other credible researchers have documented the same phenomenon. It’s well known and thoroughly proven.

There’s nothing theoretical or questionable here: your 15-20 expected investment returns on a passive, diversified stock portfolio are inversely correlated to the market valuation at the beginning of the holding period.

Are 4% withdrawal rates really safe? The other factors you need to consider for early retirement.
Click To Tweet

So, what do you do with this information? Well, it depends on the market valuations.

If valuations are favorable, you don't have to do anything – just enjoy the ride with a normal, passive investment portfolio.

However, as I write this post, market valuations remain unfavorable, painting a 15-20 year expected return on a diversified portfolio of stocks likely insufficient to support a 4% withdrawal rate safely.

Related: The inconvenient truth about buy & hold

Again, nobody has a crystal ball, but the statistics point to a margin of safety that’s thinner than most retirees would like. This assumes, of course, a passive buy and hold investment strategy.

However, you’re not a victim to market valuations: you can do something about it.

How To Improve Your Safe Withdrawal Rate In Retirement

For example, I personally apply a more active investment strategy for the very reasons cited in this article. I’m not willing to accept the unfavorable expected returns of a passive portfolio purchased during a period of excessive valuations and unfavorable trends.

Likewise, a retiree with a real estate portfolio would be looking at the numbers very differently depending on how his portfolio is structured. The rental income from his real estate could easily provide a yield in excess of 4%.

See My Related Book…

The 4% Rule - Safe withdrawal rates in retirement
Amazon Kobo B&N iBooks

The point is the conventional investment wisdom about safe withdrawal rates is only applicable to a portfolio where the investment returns result from a passive buy and hold investment strategy using a traditional asset allocation of paper assets.

In other words, the concept of a safe withdrawal rate applies regardless of your investment strategy, but the 4% or 3% rule assumes your investment returns will be similar to a passive buy and hold investor with a conventional asset allocation. You don't have to accept that assumption: you can do something about it.

All this analysis begs another, possibly more important question: rather than start with the assumption of a buy and hold investment strategy for equities and ask how much spending the portfolio can support, I believe the more interesting question is, “What investment strategy can realistically support the spending level I require?”

In other words, many people make the mistake of assuming buy and hold is the only game in town. I disagree wholeheartedly.

I believe buy and hold is a special case investment strategy that should only be employed when valuations imply an acceptable risk to reward ratio.

It’s not the all-weather investment strategy that conventional wisdom claims.

There are many alternatives available, but that discussion won't be covered here because it’s beyond the scope of this already-too-long blog post.

Are 4% withdrawal rates truly safe? Learn how to factor in market valuations and conditions when saving for retirement so you can safeguard your income later on.

In summary, this analysis of safe withdrawal rates from retirement savings in an environment of excessive market valuation and unfavorable trends should give you several avenues to pursue:

  • You can reduce your monthly withdrawal rate from retirement savings to something less than 4% to balance the reduced investment return expectation.
  • You can increase retirement savings while maintaining the same nominal withdrawal rate, thus reducing your withdrawal rate in percentage terms (i.e. increase savings from 25 times first year withdrawal rate to 33 times or more).
  • You can change investment strategy from passive to some alternative offering a higher mathematical expectation or higher income that would support the higher withdrawal rate.

Each one of these avenues can point you in the direction of greater retirement security given current market valuations and trends.

Also, if you would like more help in understanding How Much Money You Need To Retire, please check out my book on the subject.

Finally, please share how this post affects your thinking about retirement planning strategy.

I look forward to hearing your comments below…

Invest Like Todd!

A better investment strategy than buy and hold - Makes more by risking less

Discover the scientific investment process Todd developed during his hedge fund days that he still uses to manage his own money today. It’s all simplified for you in this turn-key system that takes just 30 minutes per month.

Learn more… »

Want a PDF of this article? We'll email it to you!

+ =

Related...

Are Safe Withdrawal Rates Really Safe?
Average Savings By Age: How Do You Rank?
FM 001: The Truth About Retirement Income & Dave Ramsey's Shocking ROI and Safe Withdrawal Rate Assumptions with Wade Pfau
FM 009: How To Convert Your Volatile Investment Portfolio Into Automatic Income With Wade Pfau
FM 010: How To Engineer Your Wealth Using Retirement Calculators With Darrow Kirkpatrick
Is It Safe To Withdraw 4% From Retirement Savings?
Preparing For Retirement - The 5 Essential Questions
Reduce Your Risk by Increasing Leverage - 5 Uncommon Strategies
Retirement Planning Checklist
The Dirty Dozen Retirement Planning Mistakes to Avoid
401(k) Early Withdrawal Calculator
Retirement Withdrawal Calculator
Share:FacebookTwitterPinterestLinkedIn

Comments

  1. AvatarLarry Weber

    Thank you for your response. I’ve been thinking about this issue for several weeks now and agree 100% with your analysis.

    I’m planning on writing a position paper on the subject to clarify my own thinking on the subject. I don’t think the mainstream investment industry fully grasps how much high/low valuations impact not only “safe” withdrawal rates but also long term investment returns.

    As you know, the real profit on any investment is usually made when you buy not when you sell. The valuation level at time of purchase is a good indicator of the future investment return.

    Dr. Shiller and others have shown that the P/E ratio impacts long term investment returns as well. High valuations above the historical norm at the time of purchase substantially reduce real returns down the road. Low valuations at the time of purchase, generally provide higher real returns in future years.

    A simple way that I remember this concept: “When valuations are high, stocks generally die”. “When valuations are low, Stocks usually grow”. The P/E ratio is one of those mathematical expectation tools that can really help us see through the investment fog.

    Thank you for your insights. God Bless.

This article’s comments are closed.

Financial Freedom For Smart People
Book Series

the leverage equation
Amazon Kobo B&N iBooks
how much money do I need to retire
Amazon Kobo B&N iBooks
4 Rule Safe Withdrawal Rates In Retirement
Amazon Kobo B&N iBooks
Variable Annuity Pros and Cons
Amazon Kobo B&N iBooks
Investment Fraud
Amazon Kobo B&N iBooks
Don’t Hire a Financial Coach!
Amazon Kobo B&N iBooks
  • How Anyone Can Retire Early In 10 Years (Or Less!)
  • How To Build Wealth (It’s Ridiculously Simple)
  • The Ten Commandments Of Wealth Building
  • The Secret To Happiness… And Why It Has Nothing To Do With Money
  • 12 Tips To Build Wealth For Early Retirement
  • How To Get Out Of Debt – The Complete Guide
  • The Great Bond Bubble Is Now! What’s Next…
  • Pay Off Mortgage Early Or Invest: The Complete Guide
  • What Endurance Athletes Can Teach Us About Building Wealth
  • The Parable Of The Mexican Fisherman And Investment Banker
  • FM 026: Understanding What Todd Means By “Epochal Change”
  • When is the Right Time to Buy Life Insurance?
  • How To Consolidate Debt, The Smart Way
  • How Much Does Life Insurance Cost?
  • How Anyone Can Retire Early In 10 Years (Or Less!)
  • How To Build Wealth (It’s Ridiculously Simple)
  • How Does Life Insurance Work?
  • Do I Need Life Insurance? Why Is Life Insurance Important?
  • How Much Life Insurance Do You Need?
  • Optimize Your 401(k) Today [Includes Free 401(k) Analysis Tools]
  • Are Safe Withdrawal Rates Really Safe?
  • 7 Key Reasons Why Financial Education Is Your Best Investment
  • 10 Commandments of Investment Strategy
  • Andrew Carnegie “The Gospel Of Wealth”
  • Multiple Streams Of Income – Truth Revealed
  • Retirement Planning Checklist
  • The Smart Alternative To Retirement Planning
  • What Is A Good Investment?
  • Pay Off Debt Or Build Wealth? What To Do First…
  • The Minimalist Guide To Financial Planning
  • Retirement Planning
  • Investment Advice
  • Financial Advice
  • Wealth Building
  • True Wealth
  • How Much Do I Need to Retire?

Testimonials

I just wanted to say a great THANK YOU VERY MUCH! for helping me this last 6 months. I knew I wanted to retire and do something with my money but felt lost and uncertain. I used to think investing was just about diversifying and asset allocation, but you gave me a grander view and the confidence to run my own portfolio. Your course was well honed-out, all the pieces fit together, and the learning steps were in the right order. And you were the right person to teach it to me!
Vo ToHouston, Texas
See All Testimonials Legal Disclaimer

More from Financial Mentor

New Visitors Start Here
Financial Freedom Course
A Smarter Way To Invest
Todd’s Books

Click Below To Learn How To...

Invest smart. Build wealth. Retire early. Live free.

Financial Mentor

Get Your FREE Wealth Building Tooklit:

  • FREE COURSE: 52 Weeks To Financial Freedom
  • FREE BOOK: 18 Essential Lessons From A Millionaire
  • Tools and Tips Not Found On This Site
Free instant access

Calculators

Retirement
Mortgage
Credit Card
Debt Payoff
Auto Loan
Savings
Investment
Loan
Personal Finance
Compound Interest Calculator
Debt Snowball Calculator

Learn More

About Financial Mentor
About Financial Coaching
Our Books
7 Steps To 7 Figures
Podcast
Todd R. Tresidder
Press Room
Contact

Resources

How To Invest Your Money
Recommended Reading
Recommended Tools
New Visitors Start Here
Ask Todd
Courses
Books
Audio

Facebook Twitter Google Plus LinkedIn YouTube RSS Pinterest iTunes

Home   Privacy Statement   Terms of Use   Contact Us

Copyright © 2000–2023• Financial Mentor • All Rights Reserved Worldwide
The information contained on this web site is the opinion of the individual authors based on their personal observation, research, and years of experience. The publisher and its authors are not registered investment advisers, attorneys, CPA’s or other financial service professionals and do not render legal, tax, accounting, investment advice or other professional services. The information offered by this web site is general education only. Because each individual’s factual situation is different the reader should seek his or her own personal adviser. Neither the author nor the publisher assumes any liability or responsibility for any errors or omissions and shall have neither liability nor responsibility to any person or entity with respect to damage caused or alleged to be caused directly or indirectly by the information contained on this site. Use at your own risk. Additionally, this website may receive financial compensation from the companies mentioned through advertising, affiliate programs or otherwise. Rates and offers from advertisers shown on this website change frequently, sometimes without notice. While we strive to maintain timely and accurate information, offer details may be out of date. Visitors should thus verify the terms of any such offers prior to participating in them. The author and its publisher disclaim responsibility for updating information and disclaim responsibility for third-party content, products, and services including when accessed through hyperlinks and/or advertisements on this site.
×

Yes, Send My FREE Wealth Building Blueprint!

  • E-Course: “52 Weeks to Financial Freedom”
  • Audio: Get my top tips
  • E-Book: "18 Essential Lessons From A Self-Made Millionaire"


×

Yes, Send My FREE Wealth Building Blueprint!

  • E-Course: “52 Weeks to Financial Freedom”
  • Audio: Get my top tips
  • E-Book: "18 Essential Lessons From A Self-Made Millionaire"


×

Yes, email me a screenshot of my calculator results!

We’ll email you a screen print of the calculator you just completed, exactly as it appears on your screen. We don’t save any of your data: it’s just an image. You can unsubscribe whenever you want.


Calculator screenshot sample
Sample Screenshot
×



Withdrawal Rate Image
×

Enter Your Email And We’ll Send You A Convenient PDF Of This Article!



Withdrawal Rate Image
×

Tell us where to send your 2 video guide showing UNCOMMON strategies for ACCURATELY calculating how much you need to retire…



Free video tutorial
×

Tell Me When The Course Is Ready!

You’ll learn how to make more by risking less.


×

Tell Me When The Course Is Ready!

You’ll learn how to calculate your retirement number with confidence.


×

Hey, I understand that buying this course is an important decision. That’s why I let you…

Test Drive The Course – FREE!
Get 5 Sample Lessons Immediately

  • No cost or obligation.
  • No hooks or gimmicks.
  • The goal is to let you experience the quality for yourself.
  • I just need your email address to send them to you.
  • You can unsubscribe anytime.
Yes! Send me 5 sample lessons
No cost or obligation. Quit any time.
The only way you lose is by not trying.
×

Take your financial strategy to the next level…

Get 5 FREE Video Lessons With Uncommon Insights To Accelerate Your Financial Growth

  • No cost or obligation.
  • No hooks or gimmicks.
  • The goal is to let you experience the quality for yourself.
  • I just need your email address to send them to you.
  • You can unsubscribe anytime.
Yes! Send me 5 sample lessons
No cost or obligation. Quit any time.
The only way you lose is by not trying.